In 2022, for the film Weird: The Al Yankovic Story, Yankovic rerecorded the track, as well as four others. In the film, Yankovic's fictional father reveals that he was raised Amish, and Yankovic finds a lyric sheet written by his father called "Amish Paradise" and decides to perform the song.

You know I shun fancy things like electricity. 'Weird Al' Yankovic: Amish Paradise: Directed by 'Weird Al' Yankovic. With Steve Jay, Jon Schwartz, Jim West, 'Weird Al' Yankovic. 'Weird Al' Yankovic performs a parody of Coolio's song "Gangsta's Paradise", but talking about the Amish culture.

Although Weird Al received permission from Interscope Records to parody “Gangsta’s Paradise,” rapper Coolio didn’t give Yankovic consent to write the parody “Amish Paradise.” After the Grammy Awards in 1995, Coolio spoke out against the parody, saying, “ [I] ain’t with that … I think that my song was too serious …

Weird Al: As I walk through the valley where I harvest my grain, I take look at my wife and realize she's very plain. But that's just perfect for an Amish like me. You know I shun fancy things like electricity. 'Weird Al' Yankovic: Amish Paradise: Directed by 'Weird Al' Yankovic. With Steve Jay, Jon Schwartz, Jim West, 'Weird Al' Yankovic.